How Helpful Are Character Checks?

How Helpful Are Character Checks?


In our seek for self-knowledge, we’ve all probably taken one (or a number of) persona exams. The aim is to realize insights about ourselves—why we’re the best way we’re. However are these exams any good? Do they precisely measure persona? Are they really useful for self-understanding? The solutions are advanced.

article continues after commercial

Let me deal with three of the most well-liked persona exams: The Myers-Briggs Kind Indicator (MBTI), the Enneagram, and the Huge 5.

The Myers-Briggs is probably the most extensively administered psychological take a look at. It’s primarily based on Carl Jung’s principle of psychological sorts. It was constructed by the mom and daughter staff of Katherine Prepare dinner Briggs and Isabel Briggs Myers. Katherine Briggs used Jungian notions of persona to investigate characters in literature. Though the MBTI is predicated on Jungian principle, it was actually Isabel Myers’ interpretation of that principle that lies beneath the take a look at’s building. The MBTI has 4 dimensions (Introversion-Extraversion; INtuition-Sensing; Pondering-Feeling; Judging-Perceiving). Mixtures yield 16 persona sorts, and customers get to know their four-letter “kind” (e.g., ESTJ; INFP).

The Enneagram has historic roots, derived from Babylonian and Sufi traditions. It yields 9 sorts, represented numerically. The categories have descriptive labels (e.g., “The Reformer,” “The Achiever,” “The Peacemaker,”). Not like the MBTI, whose “official” take a look at is printed by the Myers-Briggs Company, there are numerous exams for assessing the Enneagram.

The Huge 5 was primarily developed as a analysis software to assist perceive how persona pertains to quite a lot of outcomes, from well-being to tutorial success, to potential as an worker. It consists of 5 dimensions: Neuroticism, Extraversion, Openness to Expertise, Conscientiousness, and Agreeableness. Though there are numerous measures to evaluate the Huge 5 the most typical is the “NEO,” so named for the primary 3 dimensions.

article continues after commercial

Is This Take a look at Any Good?

A primary concern is the underlying principle behind the take a look at. As talked about, the MBTI was primarily based loosely on Jung’s principle. The Enneagram principle pre-dates the sphere of psychology and is an interpretation of historic traditions relating to persona sorts. The Huge 5 advanced after many years of analysis on completely different persona traits and was the results of lowering dozens of proposed traits into 5 core, steady, “higher-order” traits.

Any good take a look at must exhibit good validity, measuring what it’s presupposed to measure, and reliability (i.e., stability, so that you just don’t get completely different scores for a similar particular person at completely different occasions).

Each the MBTI and the Enneagram have been criticized by persona psychologists for an absence of stable proof of validity and reliability. For instance, the forced-choice format of the self-report MBTI would possibly result in a change from an Extravert to an Introvert as a result of the test-taker modified their responses to a few gadgets, suggesting issues with take a look at reliability. As well as, typologies endure from the truth that the test-taker is put right into a class. For instance, chances are you’ll be labeled an Extravert (“E”) or an “Introvert” (I) and that’s your kind. Truly, persona dimensions are steady, with individuals being roughly introverted or extraverted, and the typology doesn’t differentiate robust introverts from comparatively weak introverts.

However, the Huge 5 measures, such because the NEO, have been extensively validated. They provide steady scores on every of the 5 persona traits, so the consumer can inform if they’re robust or weak on every trait. The Huge 5 measures, nonetheless, are principally used for analysis and don’t usually supply the detailed interpretations attribute of the opposite two measures.

article continues after commercial

Along with these well-known persona measures, there are loads of so-called persona exams on the market on the Web. One needs to be particularly involved concerning the interpretation of persona take a look at outcomes.

The Barnum Impact

Named for P.T. Barnum, who famously stated, “there’s a sucker born each minute,” the Barnum Impact happens when individuals are given obscure interpretations of their persona take a look at scores that would match nearly anybody. That is the impact that horoscopes, fortune tellers, and charlatans create once they counsel the knowledge they supply applies to a person when it might actually apply to virtually anybody (e.g., “Generally you may be loud, outgoing, and a individuals particular person, however different occasions you may be quiet, shy, and reserved.”) Be cautious. Many on-line “persona exams” give these obscure interpretations that would apply to simply about anybody (and among the MBTI and Enneagram kind descriptions appear a bit “Barnumy” to me.)

Character Checks: What Are They Good For?

Character exams have been initially developed as analysis instruments to higher perceive particular person variations in individuals. Later, they have been used for a number of functions. Some persona exams, such because the MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Character Stock), are used to diagnose completely different psychological problems. Different persona exams, such because the Hogan Assessments, are used for personnel choice and for creating workers and managers.

Character Important Reads

What about exams that people take for self-exploration: the MBTI, Enneagram, and the Huge 5? Merely put, they need to be “taken with a grain of salt.” Understand that these solely provide you with some indication of the persona traits that you could be possess, however they aren’t precise and may be completely incorrect. Anyone take a look at end result could possibly be affected by the test-taker, who would possibly attempt to “second guess” the take a look at, or reply in a socially-desirable approach.

article continues after commercial

Keep in mind too, that persona just isn’t future. Possessing sure fascinating (or undesirable) traits doesn’t imply that you’re locked into sure behavioral patterns. Traits signify tendencies—patterns of conduct—and we are able to escape of tendencies. Furthermore, the scenario additionally comes into play. For instance, an introvert would possibly, in sure conditions, behave extra like an extravert, and vice versa.

Briefly, don’t get too hung up on the outcomes of your persona exams.


Hook, J. N., Corridor, T. W., Davis, D. E., Van Tongeren, D. R., & Conner, M. (2021). The Enneagram: A scientific assessment of the literature and instructions for future analysis. Journal of Scientific Psychology, 77(4), 865-883.
King, S. P., & Mason, B. A. (2020). Myers‐Briggs kind indicator. The Wiley Encyclopedia of Character and Particular person Variations: Measurement and Evaluation, 315-319.
Snyder, C. R., Shenkel, R. J., & Lowery, C. R. (1977). Acceptance of persona interpretations: the” Barnum Impact” and past. Journal of consulting and scientific psychology, 45(1), 104.
Pittenger, D. J. (1993). The utility of the Myers-Briggs kind indicator. Evaluation of academic analysis, 63(4), 467-488.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *